Showing posts with label antagonism. Show all posts
Showing posts with label antagonism. Show all posts

Tuesday, July 16, 2013

Here's a Ricki Lake clip from the 90s that will make you remember when things were worse.

Goths have it easy these days, in my opinion. People are way, way more comfortable with it than they used to be. Back in the nineties, this kind of programming was considered to be OK. It wouldn't be, anymore.


Monday, July 15, 2013

LigeiaResurrected - "Goth Talk - Dealing with Bullies"

Here's a less "positive" video in regard to bullying. One thing that I do like about this video though is that LigeiaResurrected is very blunt about how far bullies may go, and she doesn't sugar coat things.


Kill Natalie - "Goth Talk: dealing with bullies"

Here is some interesting and sound advice on how to deal with bullies.


Sunday, February 17, 2013

Marilyn Manson on "The Phil Donahue Show" in 1995

We've really come a long way since those days. It's been almost twenty years since this show, and I think the general public has gotten a different point view about goth and industrial music and events since those days. Of course, the average Joe or Jane on the street is still probably going to think that people who present as goth are strange and might have problems, but it seems like, for the most part, only significantly conservative people at this point in time think that goths, by definition, worship Satan and are prone to violence. As much as we want to complain about the lack of mainstream acceptance of underground subcultures now, when we look back at things like the below video, we get a stark sense of perspective. That doesn't mean we should rest on our laurels, but we have made large amounts of progress.

In this episode of "The Phil Donahue Show", there is a debate about the safety of moshing, and there are some interesting points that are even applicable today, such as the need for competent security at clubs and the discussion about blaming media for personal actions. Also, I notice the level of shock value that Marilyn Manson attempts, and back then, it was considered super edgy, particularly to the mainstream. Now that I've been into the scene for a while, I see that Marilyn Manson is about as hardcore as a jar of Metamucil, but that shouldn't detract from his merits as an artist. I largely side with the Marilyn Manson and the other music scene people on there, although I think Manson could have worded some things better, particularly in regard to suicide as a result of music. I understand what he was trying to say, but I think he might have been a little too focused on being hardcore to try to get his point across properly. I think the point that he was trying to allude to, but didn't really come out and say, was the fact that the suicides people try to blame on music were probably a result of anything but the music and that we should be focusing on what the real problems were with these people as opposed to looking to create a scapegoat.

Anyway, sit back and enjoy some old 90s "trash TV".


Saturday, January 12, 2013

Commentary on LeahMouse's "What Goth is NOT!"

Last week, I took a look at goth is, but this week, I think it's worth it to look at what goth isn't. Before you read the rest of the article, you may want to watch this YouTube video by LeahMouse, "What Goth is NOT!" because this post is essentially a commentary on it.



First, I want to touch on her explanation that it's a misconception that goths are innately depressed. I wholeheartedly agree with this. Based on personal experiences in the club scene, interacting with people regarding my musical interests, and dealing with the business of this site, I have no reason to believe that goths, as a whole, are overwhelmingly, overtly, and expressively depressed. I do know goths who do suffer from depression, but these people are certainly not depressed because they're goth or because they're trying to project a goth image. These people may have been somewhat attracted to the goth subculture due to their depression, but that relationship seems secondary to other reasons, such as the enjoyment of art and affinity to the music and style.

Most people who I've spoken to within the goth-industrial subculture, regardless of faction or fine-tuned identity, have been relatively well-adjusted people who lead happy lives and have a healthy self-esteem. The people who do have problems are those who have problems in regard to things that have nothing to do with the goth subculture, but from other internal or external causes. Of course, I do not claim to be the definitive expert on all people who identify as goth, but speaking from my own personal experience, I agree with LeahMouse on this point.

In regard to her next point about the religion and religiosity of people within the goth subculture, I think that's one of those points that has been beaten into the ground a bit over the years, especially in regard to goths in the US. The US has become more secular of a nation over time, and from my observations, the goth community has just as significant of a secular influence as everyone else does. From my observations, the only people who really care about the religion of a goth person are the people who care too much about the religion of anyone else. It wouldn't matter if the people in question were goths, preps, geeks, or whatever. It's not the kind of thing I would lose too much sleep over, because there is no pleasing that group of people who likes to stick their noses into the religious practices of others.

As for the points about troublemaking and delinquent behavior, I think LeahMouse could have been a little more eloquent and worded her presentation a bit better, but I agree with the ideas she presents.

People tend to look at the outside of a person and make immediate judgments based on it and previous knowledge and experience. Many people have preconceived notions of what "goth" is, and will make automatic attributions on sight. Obviously, it's unfair to judge someone by the outside, but everyone does it. I do it. You do it. If you say you don't do it from time to time, I'll immediately call you a liar. The key thing is recognizing that you do it and making an attempt to dig deeper. In regard to the goth subculture, that means that people should try to educate themselves on what it means to be goth. I don't have wild expectations that people are going to dedicate vast amounts of time delving into books, articles, and videos about every part of goth subculture, but even just a little bit of passing interest would go a long way and help to wipe away a lot of misconceptions. There are a number of misconceptions (e.g. widespread practicing ritual sacrifice) that would go away in a person with even the tiniest modicum of education on the goth subculture.

As for finding appreciation in darker beauty, I think that is part of why people who are outside of the scene get confused in regard to what it means to be goth. For instance, a goth person may find aesthetic pleasure in skeletons or blood, but that doesn't mean he or she has any interest in killing anyone to make these aesthetics come to realistic fruition. Those two things have absolutely nothing to do with one another, but a lot of people who don’t get the subculture can't really wrap their heads around it. Again, based on personal experience, I have no reason to believe that goths would have any greater propensity to perform violent acts than a non-goth, but some people tend to get worried by the level of comfort that goths have in regard to discussing the darker and sometimes more grotesque parts of life.

Finally, goth is not all about dressing in black, as LeahMouse said. There isn't a whole lot I can say about this that would not completely dominate the post, because goth fashion is something that entire magazines and websites are devoted to talking about. But in short, ignoring those who are not presenting as goth at all from a fashion standpoint, even among those who are trying to present a goth image, it's not always about dressing in all black. Depending on the type of goth, you may not even dress in black at all. There is just such a wide variety.

In short, watch this woman's video. She brings up some excellent points about what goth is not. If we want to set boundaries for the subculture, it's just as important to figure out what goes out as to what goes in.

Monday, January 7, 2013

You know what's deplorable? Misogyny.

As my readers should know by now, Unter Null is one of my favorite musicians. I've not had the opportunity to have the years of experience with her music that some people have, but in the short time that I've listened to it, it's moved me. Moreover, based on the half a shot glass's worth of information I have gathered about her personality, Erica has my respect in that category, too. In particular, I like how she's able to take things in stride and change the direction of an annoying situation using sarcasm.

(Photo by Ericadunham, CC 3.0 Unported License)

So, Erica made a status update on her official Facebook page, today. She asked people what people would like to see in her collector's boxset edition of her next Unter Null album. Most of the suggestions were mundane, such as T-shirts, autographs, and wristbands, but someone made a comment about putting in condoms. That was kind of icky, but that was one of the things you could probably roll your eyes and just skip over. The crown jewel though was when someone said "used panties."

I'm not joking here. Someone suggested she put used panties in her box set. Regardless of whether or not that was supposed to be a joke, that was still pretty vile. Erica said, "Allowing some of these comments for posterity. This is what happens when you don't have a dick and still write music." I think she hit the nail on the head with that comment.

Why are there men out there who don't see women as people? I see this all the time when I look at communication between male fans and female artists. Luckily, I don't see it as much within the goth-industrial circles as much as I see it within some other scenes, but it still happens quite a bit. There are some men out there who think women are lesser beings than men are and don't have to be treated with the same respect.

First and foremost, if you're a guy, firing off sexually charged statements, whether in jest or seriousness, to a woman you don't know, just because she's a woman, makes you a jerk. She's a person, just like any man is a person. Moreover, as far as I know, Erica has a husband, and he's likely the only person who can get away with saying things of a sexual nature to her. If you are one of the billions of men on this planet who aren't her husband, and you say things like this to her, you're also a jerk because you're saying these things to another guy's wife.

I'm happy to see that Erica was able to handle this with such poise. If I had to guess, I'd say she probably has plenty of experience having to put up with misogynist fans, and this experience is probably something fairly common among women in the goth-industrial music scene. All things considered, this is not remotely as damaging of a situation as countless others in the past that women have had to endure, but it's still wrong and should be called out for what it is.

Thursday, January 3, 2013

What does it mean to be part of the scene?

I want to be a branch out and talk more about the scene. I think that being more in touch with how the scene operates at its core can bring added depth to an understanding of the music and the social issues that float around it. One thing that makes for an interesting discussion is the topic of acceptance. Today, I came across the YouTube channel, kazlovesbats, and that provided the inspiration for this post. There are a slew of different videos that I think matter (such as this one, this one, and this one), but I'm going to use just one video for this entry.


I think these videos can start an excellent discussion in regard to the visual aspects of goth subculture versus the actions, thoughts, and motivations. What does it mean to be goth? Then again, a more important question may be whether or not the meaning really matters.

First, from a more baseline standpoint, like she mentions in the video, everyone's definition of goth is going to be different. What she thinks goth is may be different from what someone else thinks. So, when someone puts himself or herself out there with the "goth" label, he or she is projecting a perception of self, and when people decode the message, it goes through another round of interpretation. The one communicating will send out a message based on the experience and knowledge he or she has gained over time, and the one receiving the communication will be interpreting the message based on a different set of experience and knowledge. As such, there can be a breakdown in communication. To put it more simply, if the person who claims he or she is goth has a different definition of what goth is than the person who he or she is talking to, then that automatically causes conflict. It's perfectly OK for people to have different opinions on what "goth" is, but some people don't quite seem to get that.

Furthermore, goth subculture has so many different branches and related subcultures that being able to draw a definite boundary is incredibly difficult. For example, cyber goths are a fantastic example of how boundaries get completely obliterated. A cyber goth has the goth label, but also incorporates a lot of futuristic aspects to his or her style. On a club night, it's not uncommon to see the cyber goths dancing hard to futurepop and aggrotech beats. There are a number of goths who would roll their eyes at the idea of letting KMFDM or Skinny Puppy within their sphere of influence, as there are a number of rivetheads who would groan at Bauhaus or Siouxsie and the Banshees. Likewise, there are people within both groups who shudder at the idea of VNV Nation or Funker Vogt.

But in the end, what is goth? Does someone have to be just goth? Is it unreasonable to think someone can be part of the goth, industrial, punk, and whatever other subcultures at the same time? Many musicians themselves intentionally try not to be genre-specific, because they don't want their music to become tired and irrelevant. Why would it be any different with people in their everyday lives? If people try to prescribe to a functionalist ideal of fitting into neat little boxes, they end up intentionally cutting themselves off from a significant portion of the world without a second thought.

Also, and individual's scene tendencies develop and evolve over time. People aren't going to like exactly the same things they liked when they first got into the scene, and people will behave differently. For instance, what got me into the industrial scene was listening to a lot of KMFDM and Chemlab, but then I got into the more danceable stuff like Covenant, VNV Nation, and The Crüxshadows. Then, I hit a bit of a lull, and now I'm heavily into I:Scintilla, Unter Null, and Tying Tiffany. Things change over time, but although the subtle nuances of how I self-identify may change, I still consider myself to be part of the goth-industrial subculture. (And I'm fully aware, like I implied before, that some people will completely have a fit over the idea of a goth-industrial mesh. Considering the tone of my post, I think my readers can get a good grasp of how much I care about those people's opinions on the matter, too.)

In summary, I feel like when people try hard to compartmentalize others within the scene, we end up causing lots of problems and solving none. Why should it matter how people identify? And in the end, do the opinions of those who are more goth/industrial/punk/whatever than thou really matter?

Saturday, December 29, 2012

Industrial Anti-Oppression blog

If social causes matter to you, and you're part of the goth-industrial scene, I recommend that you read the Industrial Anti-Oppression blog (for which I just realized that we share the same base generic layout template, haha!). These people stand for tearing down misogyny, racism, and homophobia within the scene.

(Public Domain License)

These people aren't quite as active in posting as they used to be, but I definitely think what they have to say is very much worth reading. They care about wanting the industrial scene to be more inclusive of people who are traditionally marginalized, and I feel that's a necessary goal for any subculture. We have to be willing to be frank about the social issues that face the scene, and we need more people like those who make the Industrial Anti-Oppression blog to give voice to those discussions. I wholeheartedly agree that the scene does have its problems, and we can't let bigoted views even be considered as worthwhile opinions.

I tip my hat off to these people, and I hope they come back and post with more frequency, once again. If you want a good place to start, check out their post about their reasons for starting the blog in the first place.

Sunday, December 23, 2012

My music is harder than yours, and you are inferior as a result.

You know what I don't understand? I don't quite understand why listening to "harder" stuff is somehow considered a badge of pride or a talking point when evaluating a musician or band. It's like these people think they'll get an achievement on XBox Live or a gold star on a progress sheet on their walls if they happen to listen to music with more bass and harsh vocal distortion than other people. When you step back and think about it, it's very difficult to even take such comments seriously. It makes you wonder if these people actually listen to themselves when they speak.


(Photo by kevin dooley / Foter / CC BY)

Usually, comments like those are a self-validation mechanism in which the poster has to make himself or herself have a confidence boost in regard his or her place within fandom. This flavor of antagonism is meant to make the person saying it feel better about his or her own music choices, which tend to be an extension of a greater self. The popularity of music that falls outside of these people's worldviews is considered to be a threat to these people's worth, so combativeness occurs.

A lot of the combativeness seems to be grounded in some level of misogyny and/or homophobia, too. A significant portion of the time, people get called sexual orientation insults or anti-woman insults in relation to listening to music that doesn't fit this almost entirely arbitrary and falsely linear level of musical composition. When I hear insults like being called a certain word for female genitalia due to listening to a certain musician, I hear this, "Your music lacks enough bass and scratchy vocals to meet my arbitrary standard. As a result, I will attribute feminine characteristics to you, and by definition, feminine characteristics are bad and should be met with hostility." Does anyone actually see logic in making a statement like that?

All in all, none of it makes sense to me. So, if you're one of those people who attributes a desire to listen to music with a certain level of harshness as some form of achievement, think to yourself, "Does this make sense? Is it logical?" Then, once you've figured that out, ask yourself why it matters to you so much in the first place. The answer may surprise you.